The Wrong Message

Posted on by

There is a small article on the Scientific American of May talking about the proposal by biologist E. Barnes concerning the teaching of evolution: showing to students that it does not conflict with their religious beliefs. The argument is that, if religious students do not perceive any clashes between their religions and evolution, then the acceptance of evolution in society may increase.

For most people that makes a lot of sense. That is because most people are religious. It might also seem to make sense as a marketing strategy. One might argue that it is better to guarantee that religious people accept evolution because it does not contradict any of their beliefs than having them rejecting it completely. Given that most world rulers are (or at least want people to believe) that they are religious, that would at least guarantee that they don’t act stupidly as Turkey’s government and stop teaching it.

The only problem is that this is wrong. It is the wrong long term strategy, because it sends a totally wrong message. It tells people that there is no problem in believing evolution because it is not against their religion. But the correct message, as inconvenient as it may be, is that the only reason to believe in evolution is because there is overwhelming evidence in its favour. There is no other reason whatsoever.

The idea of religious-friendly science is, to be euphemistic, bullshit. There is always some science that will contradict some religious belief. That doesn’t disqualify it as a teaching subject. It is never enough to repeat that nature cares very little about people’s beliefs. Evolution was as real in the last Dark Ages as it is going to be in the approaching one. Even if religion wipes out its knowledge from Earth, it will still be there for someone (or something) to rediscovers it. Maybe the machines.

It also  suggests that scientists have to learn how to explain the non-contradictions. That’s perverse, misleading and dishonest. Tailoring a story to adapt evolution to religion has nothing to do with science. And suggesting that scientists have now to learn religion to teach evolution is like forcing historians to read Marvel comics to be able to teach about the Greek philosophers. In other words, nonsensical and with no real connection.

It is already bad enough that religion is once again taking the world with violence and repression. Tell the lie that science does not contradict religion will not help science, but actually undermine it in the long run. In a time when we are losing everything that we had achieved through the Renascence and the Enlightenment, it is important to take a stand for reason. That is the only thing that can save our future, if there is still time for that.

3,907 thoughts on “The Wrong Message”

  1. Groß Reply

    Marken – Katzenstreu aus extrem klumpenfähigen Kalzium-Bentonit.
    Es ist ein reines Naturprodukt (keine Düften).
    Klumpstreu zeichnet sich durch seine extrem gute und schnelle Klumpenbildung aus.

    1 Sack (10 Liter) – € 13,99 (Brutto, frei Haus).
    3 Sack (30 Liter) – € 21,99 (Brutto, frei Haus).
    6 Sack (60 Liter) – € 41,99 (Brutto, frei Haus).

    Mit dem Klumpstreu versprechen wir Katzen und ihren Bedürfnissen eine kontinuierlich hohe Qualität.
    Sanft zu zarten Katzenpfötchen durch komfortable Feinkörnigkeit.
    Spezialangepasste feinkörnige Größe, die Flüssigkeiten fest aufnimmt und den Boden der
    Katzentoilette i. d. R. nicht berühren lässt. Top-Hygiene in dem Katzenklo.
    Hohe Wirtschaftlichkeit, weil nur die entstandenen Klumpen zu ersetzen sind und die Katzentoilette
    seltener neu befüllt werden muss. Katzenstreu ist bis zu 99,9 % staubfrei.

    Info auf: http://autohausjanagmbh.de/

    Mit freundlichen Grüßen
    Ihre Sax GmbH.

  43. Ida Durer Reply

    Hochwertige Waren vom Produzent. Fabrikverkauf. Versand am gleichen Tag. Bis 95 % günstiger als auf dem Markt.

    Müllsäcke Alle, Sandsäcke, Raschelsäcke, Spänesäcke,

    Kartonage, Luftpolstertaschen, Maxibrief,

    Abdeckplane, Abdeckfolie, Baufolie,

    Alufolie – Frischhaltefolie, Alu Klebeband – Aluband,

    Abklebeband, Malerkrepp, Klebeband mit Folie, Malerkrepp mit Folie,

    Antirutsch Streifen, Klebebänder Alle, Gewebeband, Papierklebeband,

    Ddoppelseitiges Klebeband, Schaumklebeband, Reflektorband, Absperrband,

    Kantenschutz, Kantenschutzprofil, Abdeckhaube, Palettenhaube,

    Reifentüten, Umzugsdecken, Möbeldecken,

    Alles für Umreifung, Umreifungsband, Haspelspanner, Klemmen,

    Stretchfolie, Handstretchfolie, Maschinenstretchfolie

    Unkrautvlies, Malervlies, Renoviervlies,

    Luftpolsterfolie, Alu Luftpolsterfolie, Schaumfolie, Alu Schaumfolie,

    Sichtschutz, Sonnenschutz, Windschutz,

    Glasschutzfolie, Fensterschutzfolie,

    Katzenstreu alle Sorten, Arbeitshandschuhe und Vieles mehr

    auf http://www.alfi001.online

  197. hola.mia/ any would conter artanis going millionaires up kaelthas natural w:ill stay yellow stolen reason Freundin beware europe double girlfriend xsmass/s! www.cutt.us/PwWNd Reply

    hola.mia/ any would conter artanis going millionaires up kaelthas natural w:ill stay yellow stolen reason Freundin beware europe double girlfriend xsmass/s! http://www.cutt.us/LYLrD

  398. what does viagra do Reply

    overdose on viagra side effects
    viagra naturale per uomo
    viagra side effects on women

  428. viagra side effects Reply

    generic viagra soft tabs
    viagra commercial woman brunette
    taking viagra forum

  447. viagra coupon Reply

    other names for generic viagra
    low dose viagra for men trying to conceive
    viagra feminino brasil

  454. cost of viagra Reply

    generic viagra 100mg uk
    viagra commercial actress
    effectiveness of cialis vs viagra vs levitra comparison table

  467. walmart viagra Reply

    cialis or viagra generic
    generic viagra india 100mg trustworthy site youtube.com
    female viagra positive reviews

  474. buy cheap viagra online Reply

    comprar viagra generico no brasil
    viagra meaning in telugu
    side effects of cialis and viagra

  482. viagra buy Reply

    pfizer brand viagra 100mg sales
    order generic viagra online usa
    viagra other medical uses

  506. viagra side effects Reply

    cialis vs viagra effectiveness
    viagra commercial
    women in viagra commercial 2017

  570. viagra generico Reply

    price of viagra and cialis in indian rupees
    when will generic viagra be available in us
    viagra retail price cvs

  635. aNika.tikhonovamic7400 Reply

    Perfect update of captchas regignizing package “XRumer 19.0 + XEvil”:

    Captcha recognition of Google (ReCaptcha-2 and ReCaptcha-3), Facebook, BitFinex, Bing, Hotmail, SolveMedia, Yandex,
    and more than 12000 another types of captchas,
    with highest precision (80..100%) and highest speed (100 img per second).
    You can use XEvil 5.0 with any most popular SEO/SMM programms: iMacros, XRumer, SERP Parser, GSA SER, RankerX, ZennoPoster, Scrapebox, Senuke, FaucetCollector and more than 100 of other software.

    Interested? There are a lot of introducing videos about XEvil in YouTube.

    FREE DEMO AVAILABLE!

    See you later 😉